Emily Eells: Sargent and Proust’s world
On 20 November 2025, as part of the Rencontres des Amis de Marcel Proust, Emily Eells gave a lecture at the Hôtel Littéraire Le Swann devoted to John Singer Sargent and Marcel Proust. Here is its opening.
Sargent is in the spotlight at the Musée d’Orsay this autumn, with the exhibition John Singer Sargent : Éblouir Paris and the publication of the first monograph in French on his work — Sargent : Le beau monde et son revers, which I co-wrote with Isabelle Gadoin and Charlotte Ribeyrol¹. Surprising as it may seem, this cosmopolitan painter, born in Florence in 1856 to American parents, had not yet received such honours, even though he had studied — and cut his teeth — in Paris. Proust, fifteen years his junior, probably never met Sargent; at least, the present state of our research does not allow us to claim otherwise. It is unlikely that Sargent read À la recherche du temps perdu, and Proust saw only two of his paintings. So why talk about him this evening at the Swann²? I shall try to answer that question first by concentrating on the two paintings the writer knew. Secondly, we shall see how the social circles of Proust and Sargent overlapped, notably around Count Robert de Montesquiou. The last part of this lecture will focus on the artistic world that the two men explored in their works.
The Head of an Unknown Woman, by an equally unknown artist, served as a starting point for Sargent and Proust alike. At the time Sargent painted it — around 1877, in the home town of his master, Carolus-Duran — the work sparked a lively debate about its attribution. The art critic Arsène Houssaye even believed it to be by the hand of Leonardo da Vinci and said that he knew of “nothing more beautiful since Greek art.³” Proust refers to one of the many printed reproductions of this mysterious wax head when he describes the decoration of his bedroom in “Journées de lecture”, the preface to his translation of Sésame et les lys. He evokes this image in relation to the aesthetic theories of William Morris, for whom a room is beautiful only on condition that it contains nothing but useful things. He grants a share to useless beauty, citing as an example a photograph by Brown of Botticelli’s Primavera or “the Unknown Woman” in the Lille museum (Essais, 568). Thus Proust and Sargent met in spirit — a few years apart — before this work of art known as “the Mona Lisa of Lille”⁴.
Proust saw and commented on two paintings by Sargent, even though he states in a letter to Robert de Montesquiou of 1905: “As for Sargent, […], I have never seen any.” (Corr. V, 294) He forgets that he had seen Portrait of a Boy, shown at the Salon of the Société nationale des Beaux-Arts at the Champ-de-Mars in 1891, in which Sargent depicts the wife and son of the American sculptor Augustus Saint-Gaudens. Proust devotes only three words to it in his review “Impressions des salons”, published in the May 1891 issue of Le Mensuel: “firm, natural, full of life” (Essais, 73). He was only nineteen when he formed this succinct judgement, and we know how much his aesthetic appreciation would gain in depth over time. That said, the painting did not leave a lasting impression on him.
Yet he could not forget the striking portrait that Sargent painted of Doctor Pozzi, a dazzling figure of fin-de-siècle Paris. At first he probably did not realise that the painting was by Sargent, which would explain why he writes to Montesquiou that he has never seen any. It was at Pozzi’s home, on the Place Vendôme, that Proust was confronted for the first time with his portrait, fittingly entitled Dr. Pozzi at Home (Dr Pozzi at home, 1881). Samuel Pozzi was a colleague and friend of Marcel Proust’s father, and his younger brother, Robert, would later become the assistant of this famous gynaecological surgeon. We owe to him the practice of bimanual diagnosis and the medical instrument used to grasp the cervix, still known today as “Pozzi forceps”. Marcel met him at the age of fifteen and kept the memory of a dinner at his home, on his first outing into society.
Sargent was still working under the tutelage of the portraitist Carolus-Duran when the latter took him to Pozzi’s home in the early 1880s. There Sargent is said to have noticed the portrait of Pozzi’s wife, regretting that there was not one of her husband as a pendant. Few clues reveal the terms of the commission or the exact nature of the relationship between the painter and the doctor. But there is no doubt that he was attracted to this charismatic man of irresistible charm. He was also a tireless womaniser who had affairs with some of the most famous women of the Belle Époque, among them Sarah Bernhardt. She nicknamed him “Dr God”, the same nickname that Proust would give his character Doctor Cottard, placing it in the mouth of Madame Verdurin in La Prisonnière (RTP, III 963). Geneviève Straus is also said to have fallen under Pozzi’s spell.
The rest of this lecture is published in the Bulletin Marcel Proust no. 76 (2026). Members whose subscription is up to date receive it free of charge: join for 2026.
Notes
¹ Published by Cohen & Cohen.
² The relationship between Sargent and Proust is the subject of the article I co-wrote with Stephen Coon: “Sargent and Proust: An Elusive Mouvance”, in Sargentology: New Perspectives on the Works of John Singer Sargent, special issue of Visual Culture in Britain, eds Liz Renes and Emily Moore, March 2018, pp. 49-65. See also the illustrated article “Autour de Sargent & Proust” that I published on the Proustonomics website in November 2025 (proustonomics.com/autour-de-sargent-proust).
³ See his Histoire de Léonard de Vinci, Paris, Didier & co., 1876 (2nd edition), pp. 76-77.
⁴ For an in-depth study of the Lille Unknown Woman, see Sophie Basch, Rastaquarium : Marcel Proust et le « Modern Style », Brepols, 2014, pp. 64-103.